What disagreement did Sigmund Freud have with both Josef Breuer and Jean Martin Charcot?

A. whether hypnosis was a neurological or psychological phenomenon

B. whether hypnosis should be conducted with pregnant women

C. whether hypnosis had any value as a curative remedy for patients

D. whether hypnosis was an effect of a "hidden observer" or the id '

Question

Cynthia Schultz

Advanced Placement (AP)

31 May, 17:58

What disagreement did Sigmund Freud have with both Josef Breuer and Jean Martin Charcot?

A. whether hypnosis was a neurological or psychological phenomenon

B. whether hypnosis should be conducted with pregnant women

C. whether hypnosis had any value as a curative remedy for patients

D. whether hypnosis was an effect of a "hidden observer" or the id '

+2

Answers (1)

Know the Answer?

Madyson Shannon · Answer 1

The correct answer is A. whether hypnosis was a neurological or psychological phenomenon. As you may already know, Freud was a huge fan of hypnosis and believed that it was an actual way of treating psychological problems that people were experiencing. However, these psychologists couldn't agree whether hypnosis had to do with a person's physiology or just neurons.