Read the excerpt from "What the Black Man Wants." [W]hen any individual or combination of individuals undertakes to decide for any man when he shall work, where he shall work, at what he shall work, and for what he shall work, he or they practically reduce him to slavery. [Applause.] He is a slave. That I understand Gen. Banks to do-to determine for the so-called freedman, when, and where, and at what, and for how much he shall work, when he shall be punished, and by whom punished. It is absolute slavery. It defeats the beneficent intention of the Government, if it has beneficent intentions, in regards to the freedom of our people. How does Douglass appeal to the audience's sense of logic in the excerpt?

Question

Clayton Mccarthy

English

12 December, 07:27

Read the excerpt from "What the Black Man Wants." [W]hen any individual or combination of individuals undertakes to decide for any man when he shall work, where he shall work, at what he shall work, and for what he shall work, he or they practically reduce him to slavery. [Applause.] He is a slave. That I understand Gen. Banks to do-to determine for the so-called freedman, when, and where, and at what, and for how much he shall work, when he shall be punished, and by whom punished. It is absolute slavery. It defeats the beneficent intention of the Government, if it has beneficent intentions, in regards to the freedom of our people. How does Douglass appeal to the audience's sense of logic in the excerpt?

+3

Answers (2)

Know the Answer?

Nora Sanders · Answer 1

If the options are:

by using his own personal experiences to gain their trust

by recounting emotional events to evoke sadness

by explaining the reasoning behind his argument

by describing how he plans to effect change in the US

Then the correct answer is C. by explaining the reasoning behind his argument. His reasoning is that a free person should be able to decide for themselves. The logic behind this reasoning is that it is impossible to call someone a freedman, and yet make all the decisions about his life, and choosing whether to punish him or not, and how. If that is what the government wants, he implies, then it does not want black people to be really free.

Chris · Answer 2

The answer is C for those that's not reading what dude said.