Goldman may have won the Supervisor of the Year award, but that just means they didn't look very hard for a winner. I know a couple of people who work in Goldman's division and they say that he's a real pain to work for. I'd sooner trust my friends than some awards committee.

The correct answer is A hasty generalization of the anecdotal evidence variety.

Explanation: In this case we can understand that the awards often do not evaluate certain areas that should be evaluated, this makes these awards not so valuable because in fact the possibilities in general are not fully explored.